For optometrists

The struggling reader with 20/20 vision.

A student can have clear acuity and healthy eyes and still find reading exhausting. The cause is often how the eyes team and focus up close. A few targeted questions and two quick tests, near point of convergence and near point of accommodation, will find most of these children in your chair.

Why these children are missed

Clear at 20 feet doesn't mean comfortable at 16 inches.

Screenings check distance

School and pediatric screenings test distance acuity. Convergence and accommodation at reading distance aren't part of them, so a child can pass and still struggle with every page.

Children don't complain

Most children assume everyone sees the way they do. They rarely volunteer blur, double vision or words moving. Instead it shows up as avoidance, slow work or a short attention span.

It looks like something else

Near binocular and focusing problems are easily mistaken for attention, behavior or learning problems. Your exam may be the only place someone checks the visual side.

Step 1 · Case history

Questions to ask when a student is struggling with reading or has near symptoms.

Ask the child directly, in plain words, and ask how often: never, sometimes or often. Then ask the parent what they see at homework time.

Comfort
  • Do your eyes feel tired, sore or uncomfortable when you read?
  • Do you get headaches when you read or do homework? When do they start?
  • Do you get sleepy when you read?
  • Do you feel a pulling feeling around your eyes?
Clarity and single vision
  • Do the words get blurry the longer you read?
  • Do you ever see two of the words?
  • Do the words move, jump, swim or float on the page?
  • When you look up from your desk to the board, does it take a while to clear?
Reading performance
  • Do you lose your place or skip lines?
  • Do you have to re-read the same line?
  • Do you have trouble remembering what you just read?
  • How long can you read before you need a break?
Ask the parent
  • Does your child avoid reading, or does homework take much longer than it should?
  • Do you see them cover or close one eye, tilt their head or hold the book very close?
  • Do they use a finger to keep their place, or rub their eyes while reading?
  • Are they in a reading intervention, IEP or 504 plan without the progress you'd expect?

Want a score you can track?

The Convergence Insufficiency Symptom Survey (CISS) puts 15 of these questions on a 0 to 60 scale. In children 9 to 17, a score of 16 or higher separates symptomatic convergence insufficiency from normal binocular vision. Families can also complete our symptom checklist before the visit.

Step 2 · Near point of convergence

The single most useful test for a symptomatic reader.

NPC tells you whether the eyes can hold together at reading distance. In a study comparing screening tests for convergence insufficiency in children, NPC break performed best. It takes under a minute and needs nothing more than a target and a ruler.

A receded NPC paired with near symptoms is the strongest single reason to co-manage with us for a binocular vision evaluation. A normal NPC doesn't rule out a problem if symptoms are strong, so check vergence ranges and accommodation too.

6 cm+NPC break is receded

The Convergence Insufficiency Treatment Trial used a break of 6 cm or more as its NPC criterion. Normative work by Scheiman and colleagues suggests 5 cm for break and 7 cm for recovery as clinical cutoffs.

How to measure

  1. Use an accommodative target, such as a single column of 20/30 letters, with the habitual correction in place.
  2. Move it slowly toward the bridge of the nose. Ask the child to keep it single and clear.
  3. Record the break: when they report double or you see one eye drift out.
  4. Pull the target back and record recovery, when it's single again.
  5. Repeat 3 to 5 times. An NPC that recedes with each repetition suggests poor convergence stamina.

If findings are borderline, repeat with a penlight and red-green glasses, which can reveal a receded NPC the accommodative target misses.

Step 3 · Near point of accommodation

Can the eyes focus, and keep focusing, up close?

Accommodative insufficiency often travels with convergence insufficiency, and it causes the blur, fatigue and headaches that build over a page of reading. Children rarely recognize this blur as abnormal. A monocular push-up amplitude finds it in a minute per eye.

How to measure

  1. Measure each eye separately, the other eye occluded, with the distance correction in place.
  2. Move a line of 20/30 letters slowly toward the eye until the child reports the first sustained blur.
  3. Convert to diopters: 100 ÷ distance in cm.
  4. Compare to Hofstetter's minimum for age: 15 − (0.25 × age). Two diopters or more below that minimum suggests accommodative insufficiency.

Push-up amplitudes tend to run higher than minus-lens amplitudes, so a borderline push-up result in a symptomatic child is worth a closer look. Accommodative facility with ±2.00 flippers adds useful information when you have time.

Quick check

Enter an age to see the expected minimum.
Expected minimum amplitude of accommodation by age, and the push-up blur point that suggests accommodative insufficiency
AgeExpected minimumConcern if belowBlur point farther than
613.5 D11.5 D8.7 cm
713.25 D11.25 D8.9 cm
813 D11 D9.1 cm
912.75 D10.75 D9.3 cm
1012.5 D10.5 D9.5 cm
1112.25 D10.25 D9.8 cm
1212 D10 D10 cm
1311.75 D9.75 D10.3 cm
1411.5 D9.5 D10.5 cm
1511.25 D9.25 D10.8 cm
1611 D9 D11.1 cm
1710.75 D8.75 D11.4 cm

Based on Hofstetter's minimum amplitude, 15 − (0.25 × age), and the common criterion of 2 D or more below it.

When to co-manage

Near symptoms plus any one of these.

You don't need a full binocular workup to co-manage with us. If the history points to near-vision trouble and one finding backs it up, we'll take it from there.

  • NPC break of 6 cm or more, or an NPC that recedes with repetition
  • Monocular amplitude 2 D or more below the minimum for age
  • Exophoria greater at near than at distance
  • Blur or difficulty clearing ±2.00 flippers
  • Losing place, skipping lines or poor eye movements while reading
  • A struggling reader whose acuity and eye health are normal
How to co-manage

Send the patient. We'll send them back.

Hope Vision is a vision therapy practice only. We have no optical and offer no primary eye care, so your patient comes back to you for exams, eye health, glasses and contacts.

1

Send the co-management form

Complete our co-management form or call us. Include the current prescription, cover test, NPC, NPA and a CISS score if you have one.

2

We contact the family

Our patient care coordinator reaches out to schedule and explains costs and payment options, including FES-UA scholarship funds.

3

Binocular Vision Evaluation

Dr. Toler evaluates binocular vision, accommodation, eye movements and visual processing in detail.

4

Report back to you

We send you our findings and plan, update you during therapy, and return the patient to you for all primary eye care.

Dr. Allison Toler, OD, FAAO, FOVDR
Talk it through

Not sure whether a patient would benefit from co-management? Call and ask for Dr. Toler. She's glad to talk through findings with you.

Dr. Allison Toler, OD, FAAO, FOVDR
Hope Vision Development Center · 235 Citrus Tower Blvd., Suite 107, Clermont, FL 34711 · 352-243-4673

Questions from optometrists

Will my patient buy glasses or contacts from you?

No. We don't have an optical and don't fit or sell glasses or contact lenses. If a prescription change is needed, we send the patient back to you.

Should I try base-in prism reading glasses first?

In a randomized trial of children with symptomatic convergence insufficiency, base-in prism reading glasses worked no better than placebo glasses. Office-based vision therapy with home reinforcement was the most effective treatment studied.

What about pencil push-ups at home?

Home pencil push-ups alone were less effective than office-based therapy in the Convergence Insufficiency Treatment Trial. They're a reasonable start for some patients, but if symptoms persist, co-manage with us.

What conditions do you treat?

Convergence insufficiency and other binocular vision disorders, accommodative disorders, eye movement problems, amblyopia, intermittent strabismus and visual-perceptual problems that affect learning.

Do you take insurance?

We're fee-for-service and don't bill insurance directly. We give families paperwork for out-of-network claims, and our in-office program is an approved FES-UA service through Step Up For Students. Families can also pay in full for a discount, use an in-house payment plan or finance with Cherry. See payment options.

Have a student with a receded NPC or low NPA?

Send them our way. We'll evaluate, treat and send them back to you.